What Out-of-Network Therapy Actually Costs
Out-of-network doesn't mean uncovered. It means the money moves differently: you pay for the session, then your plan reimburses part of it through a superbill. How much comes back depends on three numbers most people have never looked up, and the gap between guessing and knowing is usually a large one. Here's how to find them, plus a calculator that does the math privately in your browser.
Your numbers
What you pay per session. Pre-filled with the standard private-pay rate; edit if yours differs.
A rough plan for the year. Weekly therapy is around 40-50 sessions; biweekly is around 20.
Your plan's annual out-of-network deductible.
How much of it you've met this year.
After the deductible, the percent of the allowed amount your plan pays back. Often 50-80%.
The amount your insurer considers reasonable per session, which is usually lower than the fee. Call the number on your card and ask: what is the allowed amount for an out-of-network psychologist, CPT code 90834 (45 min) or 90837 (60 min)? Leave blank to estimate against the full fee.
Before your deductible is met
$200 per session
You pay the full fee; insurance reimburses nothing yet.
After your deductible is met
$60 per session
Insurance reimburses about $140 per session.
Sessions to meet deductible
~10 sessions
Over 12 sessions
$2,120
net, after ~$280 reimbursed
No allowed amount entered, so this estimates against your full fee. Insurers reimburse against their own (usually lower) allowed amount, so your real reimbursement is often less. Add it above for a sharper number.
This is an estimate for planning only, not a guarantee of reimbursement. Actual amounts depend on your specific plan, its allowed amounts, and how claims are processed. Confirm details with your insurer.
Want help thinking through the out-of-network path?
Book a free 15-min callWhat this looks like with my rates
Individual therapy is $200 per 50-minute session, couples are $300, and an extended 80 to 90 minute block for exposure work is $375. The calculator pre-fills the individual rate, so you can put your own plan's numbers against a real fee instead of a hypothetical one. Every rate, and what a course of treatment usually adds up to, is on the fees page.
I'm a licensed clinical psychologist in New York and Wisconsin, and I see clients by telehealth rather than from an office. Through PSYPACT that extends to 40+ states, so if you're in New York, or somewhere else that participates, the same rates and the same out-of-network math apply.
Understanding Your Out-of-Network Benefits
What does out-of-network mean?
An out-of-network (OON) provider doesn't have a contract with your insurance company. You pay the provider directly, then your plan may reimburse part of what you paid, as long as your plan includes out-of-network benefits. Many PPO and POS plans do; most HMO and EPO plans do not.
Being out-of-network is common for psychologists and doesn't mean your care isn't covered. It changes how the money moves: instead of a copay at the visit, you pay the fee and your plan pays you back later through a superbill.
What is a superbill and how do I use it?
A superbill is an itemized receipt with the diagnostic and billing (CPT) codes your insurer needs to process a claim. After your sessions, I provide one on request. You submit it to your insurance company, by their portal, app, or mail, and they apply it to your out-of-network benefits.
Reimbursement goes to you, not to me, since you've already paid for the sessions. Turnaround varies by plan, from a couple of weeks to a couple of months.
How do I find my deductible, coinsurance, and allowed amount?
Call the member services number on the back of your insurance card and ask four things: Do I have out-of-network outpatient mental health benefits? What is my out-of-network deductible, and how much have I met this year? Once it's met, what percent do you reimburse? And what is the allowed amount for CPT codes 90834 and 90837 for an out-of-network psychologist?
The allowed amount is the number people most often miss, and it's the one that most changes your estimate. Insurers reimburse a percentage of their allowed amount, not of the full fee, so knowing it turns a rough guess into a realistic plan.
Why might my real reimbursement differ from this estimate?
This calculator models the common case: a deductible, a coinsurance percentage, and an allowed amount. Real plans add wrinkles, such as separate out-of-network out-of-pocket maximums, visit limits, medical-necessity review, or a different allowed amount than you were quoted. Claims can also be processed differently than expected.
Treat the result as a planning range, not a promise. The most reliable numbers always come from your own insurer in writing.
Is the calculator private?
Yes. Everything runs in your browser. Nothing you type is sent anywhere, saved, or seen by me or anyone else. Refreshing the page clears it.
Written by Dr. Olivier van Hauwermeiren, PsyD. Licensed Clinical Psychologist, ACT & CBT
Not sure whether it pencils out?
That's a reasonable thing to work through before committing to anything. I offer a free, confidential 15-minute intro call, no commitment, and we can talk about the cost alongside whether the work is a fit.
Book a Free Intro Call